Since author J. R. R. Tolkein’s The Hobbit was first published in 1937, millions of readers (and moviegoers, too) have found themselves engrossed in the adventures of the residents of Middle-earth. And the biopic Tolkien explores the man behind the fantasies—and the stories that inspired them.
Tolkien explores the youth and early adulthood of the legendary fantasy writer (played by Harry Gilby and Nicholas Hoult). Orphaned as a boy, he received a scholarship to attend King Edward’s School, where he met a group of aspiring artists who formed what they called the T. C. B. S.—a tight-knit brotherhood of young men who vowed to change the world through the power of art. As a teen, he also met and fell in love with fellow orphan Edith Bratt (Lily Collins). And those relationships inspired him to create the worlds that generations of readers have enjoyed exploring.
If you’re a fan of Tolkien’s fantasies—either in book or movie format—you’ll appreciate this glimpse into the people, the relationships, and the events that inspired the author’s stories. Young Tolkien is an intriguing character. Though not much attention is given to his childhood—which gave him a gift for languages—the occasional references suggest how gifted he was.
The other characters, too, are likable—and while Tolkien may be quiet, reserved, and generally awkward, the characters around him perfectly complement his personality. Edith is smart and playful and musical, encouraging him to get out of his own head and have a little fun. And the other boys are outgoing and a little rebellious. They do more than just support his creativity; they inspire his tales of adventure and camaraderie. They’re the kind of friends who would cross battlefields and risk their lives for each other. And as an older Tolkien does just that—traveling through warzones in search of a friend—his journey is filled with imagery from his own stories.
Still, while the journey through Tolkien’s youth is mixed in with some battle sequences to give it a little more action, don’t expect a thrilling film. It’s not as tense or as perilous as a Middle-earth adventure. This tale of friendships, love, and hardship may be charming, but it all feels a little aimless, the conclusion anti-climactic.
Fans of Tolkien’s work will enjoy this glimpse into the world of a beloved author, while aspiring artists will enjoy the story of inspiration and encouragement. But if you’re looking for a powerful drama or artistic insights, it won’t leave you feeling especially inspired.
Listen to the review on Reel Discovery: